This is my first review of anything, so I hope it won't be too much of a bore.
American Idol Top 4 Eliminiation
First of all, I totally support Elliot. I have to say that he has the best vocal quality - an uplifting tenor and a very rich vibrato. But since I can't vote, I can only hope that he wins the competition. But I'd have to cross my fingers, because Elliot isn't renowned to have a solid fanbase, compared to that of the other contestants. But after his performance during that Elvis night, some people might change their mind. May Athena, the goddess of underdogs, watch over him.
Anyway, I was both surprised and relieved that Chris was the one who got booted out. I was shocked that Katharine McPhee wasn't the one to go home, since she really had a bad performance night. But it goes to show that people want a female representative to enter the finals.
Anyway, I was kinda relieved that Chris was eliminated because he's bound to be a rock star. American Idol is more of a pop industry than anything else. Chris is suited to be with a band, write his own songs. You know, total rockist mentality. If Chris would have the fate of an idol who'd sing covers most of the time, I wouldn't buy his album at all. But if Chris were in the final two against Taylor or Katharine, I'd bet for him. If he'd go against Elliot, well you know.
Now the final 3. I think Katharine really has to go the extra mile, if not she's really going to get booted out soon. But I think people are expecting her to be like Christina Aguilera in her early career, or maybe another Celine Dion, and I think we've had enough of that. She's got a good voice, but I think she has the least originality. People could easily relate her to the divas of the 90s. I don't give my bet for her. I think her stay's about to end.
Taylor really has a good chance at winning it all. He's got a Freddy Flintstone personality and everybody just loves that. He also has a nice voice and it's been a long time since we've had a male soul icon rocking the airwaves. I think he's guaranteed a spot in the Final 2. But it all depends on his performances. But really, some people might have double thoughts about having Taylor as an American Idol, especially teens.
And Elliot? Well, if Elliot would win the competition I would really be surprised, and it would definitely revolutionize the music industry. Elliot has a unique style - some kinda underdog reputation, and really unique voice that I dunno what genre it really sticks to. But I'd be disappointed if Elliot would have a RnB/Hip-Hop (like J. Timberlake-ish or Usher-ish) album. It would waste his talent. But I hope he's up for something revolutionizing - something different from the Hip-Hop RnB world we're having and also something different from Carrie Underwood, Fantasia Barrino and Kelly Clarkson. Maybe something akin to Clay Aiken but definitely not like R. Studdard.
Vote for Elliot!
---------------------------
The Scholar
I think this is the first TV show to infuriate me so much. I believe it's a very stupid idea and it's more insulting that it is an opportunity for those kids. It means that they're desperate to go to college, risking fame and sudden career changes, and their own dignities as academicians! This is pure exploitation!
What I believe is that if you're smart enough and dedicated enough to go to college, you're bound to get a scholarship. There are so many foundations, organizations and schools themselves who are generous enough to offer that to you! Especially if you're one of the brightest minds in the country, which the show alleges to have. The competition for scholarships might be tough, but if you're one of the creme de la creme, you're bound to get a chance.
Being on the show is like gambling your way to college, which is not supposed to be. You have to prove yourself. And I think the show might tend to undermine the individualism of the contestants. We're not all smart in the same way. And there are also other factors to scholarships, not just smarts but also leadership skills, individualism (how a person can diversify a school population, for example), and other things.
I think the show is totally an exploit for viewer's money, and that it's doing nothing good for the education of the youth. 'Nuff said.
Recent Comments